
My Marriage Was Never Real
Chapter 2
POV of Nora Hayes
I met Ryan Sullivan in the spring of 2019, in the ER at Parkland Hospital in Dallas, and he was not my patient, he was the man holding the door open for a nurse with her arms full of charts.
"Let me help," he said. "You look like you need an extra pair of hands."
I was twenty-three. I was in my last year of nursing school. I worked nights. I slept four hours a day. I did not have time for a man.
He came back the next night. He brought coffee. Black, two sugars. He had asked the night nurse how I took it.
"I'm Ryan," he said. "My sister is a patient here. Room 412. I come every night."
His sister had been in a car accident. She was in a coma for three weeks. He sat with her every night. He read to her. He talked to her. He told me later that he had read her the same book three times.
I fell in love with him in that hospital, in the quiet hours between two and four in the morning, when the ER was slow and the lights were low and he was the only person awake besides me.
He was tender. He was tender with his sister. He was tender with me. He brought me soup when I was sick. He drove me home after a sixteen-hour shift.
In 2020, he asked me to marry him. In the hospital parking lot, at three in the morning, on my birthday. He got down on one knee. He had a ring in a small box. It was not expensive. It was simple. A thin band. He said, "Nora Hayes, I don't have much yet, but I have you, and that's enough."
I said yes. I cried. I called my mother. She cried too.
We were married on June 12, 2020, at St. Mark's in Dallas. Fifty people. My mother. His parents. His sister, awake now, in a wheelchair, smiling. Laura Bennett, our university advisor, in a navy dress, in the second row.
Laura had been my advisor at university. She had helped me get my nursing placement. She had written me a recommendation. She had been kind to me. She had also been Ryan's advisor, years earlier, when he was in law school.
I did not think about that at the time. Why would I?
After the wedding, we moved into a small house in Oak Cliff. Ryan got a job at a law firm downtown. I finished nursing school. I got a job in the ER at Parkland.
In our second year, we tried for a baby. Month after month, nothing. We went to a doctor. He ran tests. He sat us down and said, "Mrs. Sullivan, I'm sorry. Your fallopian tubes are blocked. You will not be able to conceive naturally."
I cried for a week. Ryan held me. He said, "It's all right, Nora. We don't need a baby to be a family. We have each other."
Three months later, he came home with a baby. A girl. Four months old. Dark hair. Big eyes.
"Her mother can't keep her," he said. "She's a student. She asked me to help. She trusts me. Nora, we can raise her. We can be her parents."
I held that baby in my arms and I loved her instantly. Her name was Lily. Lily Sullivan. I changed her diapers. I fed her at two in the morning. I sang to her. I taught her to walk. I taught her to read.
I never asked who her mother was. Ryan said it was a student he had helped, a girl who could not keep her baby, and I believed him, because why would I not believe him? He was tender. He was kind. He was my husband.
Except he was not my husband. And Lily was not a stranger's baby. Lily was Laura Bennett's baby. And Laura Bennett was Ryan's wife.
I found that out on a Tuesday, in the county clerk's office, holding a piece of paper that said Ryan Sullivan had married Laura Bennett in 2021, one year after he had married me.
Or rather, one year after he had pretended to marry me.
I went home that night and I looked at Lily differently. Not with less love. With more questions. Who was she? Who was her father? If Laura was her mother, and Ryan was Laura's husband, then Lily was their daughter. But Ryan had told me her mother was a student who could not keep her. That was a lie too.
Or was it? I did not know yet. I only knew that everything Ryan had told me for six years had to be checked. Every tender word. Every kind act. Every story about where he had been, who he had been with, what he had been doing.
That night, Ryan came home late. He said he had been at the office. He smelled like coffee and paper. He kissed Lily's forehead. He kissed mine.
"Long day?" I asked.
"Long," he said. "A client. A divorce. Messy."
A divorce. He was a lawyer. He handled divorces. He had told me that many times. He had told me about his clients, about the women who came to him crying, about the men who hid money, about the lies people told in court.
He had never told me about his own divorce. Because he had never been divorced. He had never been married to me.
I made dinner. I put Lily to bed. I read her a story. The same story I had read her a hundred times. A girl who finds a door in a wall and walks through it into a garden.
Lily fell asleep with her hand in mine. I sat there for a long time. I looked at her face. At her dark hair. At her eyes. They were not Ryan's eyes. They were not Laura's eyes, as far as I could remember. They were her own.
I went downstairs. Ryan was on the couch, watching the news. I sat next to him. I did not touch him. I did not say anything about the certificate. Not yet.
"Ryan," I said. "Do you remember our wedding?"
He smiled. "Of course. Best day of my life."
"Who was there?" I asked. "In the second row. In the navy dress."
He did not miss a beat. "Laura Bennett. Your advisor. Why?"
"No reason," I said. "I was just thinking about her."
He nodded. He went back to the news. I went to bed. I lay awake until three in the morning, listening to Ryan breathe next to me, thinking about six years of tenderness, and wondering how much of it had been real, and how much of it had been a performance.
The next morning, I called Laura Bennett. I had her number in my phone from university. I had not called her in years.
She answered on the second ring. "Nora? Is that you?"
"Yes," I said. "It's me. Can we meet? For coffee?"
There was a pause. A long pause. "Of course," she said. "When?"
"Today," I said. "At noon. At the café on Main Street."
"All right," she said. "I'll be there."
I hung up. I looked at myself in the mirror. I was twenty-nine years old. I was an ER nurse in Dallas. I had raised a child who was not mine. I had loved a man who was not my husband.
And at noon, I was going to meet the woman who was his wife.
You may also like





