
My Marriage Was Never Real
Chapter 3
POV of Nora Hayes
Laura Bennett was already at the café when I arrived, sitting by the window, in a navy dress, and for a second I was twenty-three again, sitting in her office at university, asking her to write me a recommendation.
She stood up. She smiled. "Nora. You look wonderful."
"You look the same," I said. It was true. She was thirty-nine. She had grey in her hair now. She had lines around her eyes. She still smiled like a woman who had never done anything wrong.
We ordered coffee. She asked about the hospital. She asked about Lily. She asked about Ryan.
"Ryan is well," I said. "He's at the office."
She nodded. "He works too hard. He always did."
I put my hands around my cup. I looked at her. I said, "Laura, I went to the county clerk's office yesterday. To reissue my marriage certificate."
Her hand stopped. Just for a second. Then she picked up her cup again.
"And?" she said.
"There is no record," I said. "No license. No marriage. The certificate Ryan gave me was a forgery."
She did not look surprised. She looked tired. Like a woman who had been waiting for this day for a long time.
"I see," she said.
"And then I found another record," I said. "Ryan Sullivan and Laura Bennett. Married in 2021. Five years ago."
She put her cup down. She looked out the window. "Yes," she said. "That's true."
Just like that. Yes. That's true. No denial. No apology. No explanation.
"So you are his wife," I said. "And I am nothing. I raised your daughter for five years, and I am nothing."
"Lily is my daughter," she said. "Yes. I gave birth to her. In 2020. I was thirty-four. I was not married then. Ryan helped me. He said he would raise her with you. He said you would love her. And you did."
I stared at her. "You gave me your baby. You let me raise your baby. And you married her father a year later."
"I married Ryan because I had to," she said. "Not because I wanted to. Because I had no choice."
"What does that mean?" I asked.
She leaned forward. She lowered her voice. "Nora, you don't know who Ryan is. You think you do. You think he's tender. You think he's kind. He is, when it suits him. But he is also a man who will do anything to keep his father's money."
"His father?" I said. "His father died when he was in law school."
"His father did not die," she said. "His father is alive. In Houston. He cut Ryan off when Ryan was twenty-seven. He said, 'Marry Laura Bennett, or you get nothing. Not a dollar. Not the firm. Not the house.'"
I felt the floor tilt under me. "Why you? Why Laura Bennett?"
"Because my father owned the building Ryan's firm was in," she said. "Because my family had money. Because Ryan's father wanted a merger, not a marriage. He wanted our families joined. He wanted Ryan to marry me."
"And Ryan agreed?" I asked.
"He agreed," she said. "He married me in 2021. In secret. No ceremony. Just a paper, filed with the county. The real one. The one that counts."
"And me?" I said. "What was I?"
"You were the woman he loved," she said. "He told me that. He said, 'Laura, I love Nora. I will not leave her. I will keep her, and I will keep you, and I will keep the money.'"
"You let him keep two women?" I said. "You let him lie to me for six years?"
"I tried to stop him," she said. "I told him to tell you. He never did."
I walked out of the café. I drove to the hospital. I called my mother.
"Mom," I said. "I need you to come and get Lily. Tonight. Take her to your house. For a few days."
"Why?" she asked. "What's wrong?"
"I'll tell you later," I said. "Just come. Please."
She came. She took Lily. Lily cried. She did not want to go. I hugged her. I said, "Mommy will see you in a few days, sweetheart. I promise."
Mommy. I was not her mother. I was not Ryan's wife. I was a woman who had raised a child for five years, and loved a man for six, and had nothing on paper to show for either.
That night, Ryan came home. He found the house empty. No Lily. No dinner. Just me, sitting at the kitchen table, with two pieces of paper in front of me.
One was the fake certificate. The other was the real marriage license. Ryan Sullivan and Laura Bennett. 2021.
He stopped in the doorway. He looked at the papers. He did not look surprised.
"Nora," he said. "Let me explain."
"Explain what?" I said. "Explain that you married Laura Bennett five years ago? Explain that you forged my certificate? Explain that you told me I was barren, so I would raise your wife's child and never ask for one of my own?"
He sat down across from me. He put his hands on the table. His hands were shaking.
"I did it for us," he said. "For you and me. My father said if I didn't marry Laura, he would cut me off. I would lose the firm. I would lose the house. I would lose everything. I couldn't do that to you. I couldn't do that to Lily."
"You did it for the money," I said.
"I did it for us," he said again.
"No," I said. "You did it for the money. You chose Laura's money over me. You chose a real marriage to Laura, and a fake marriage to me, and you thought I would never find out."
He reached across the table. He tried to take my hand. I pulled it away.
"Nora, please," he said. "I love you. I have always loved you. Laura is a business arrangement. You are my life."
I stood up. I picked up the two papers. I folded them. I put them in my bag.
"Ryan," I said. "Tomorrow morning, I am going to see a divorce lawyer. Except I can't divorce you. Because we were never married. So I am going to see a lawyer about something else. About fraud. About a forged certificate. About six years of my life."
He stood up too. "Nora, don't do this. Don't throw away six years."
"I am not throwing away six years," I said. "You threw them away. The day you forged that certificate. The day you married Laura. The day you told me I was barren."
I walked to the door. I stopped. I turned around.
"And Ryan," I said. "One more thing. Tomorrow, when I walk into that lawyer's office, I am going to say three sentences. I have been practicing them all day. Do you want to hear them?"
He nodded. He looked afraid. For the first time in six years, Ryan Sullivan looked afraid of me.
"I am unmarried," I said. "I have no children. The assets are mine, and mine alone."
I walked out. I did not look back. Behind me, I heard him say my name, once, quietly, like a man who had just watched his whole life walk out the door.
"Nora."
I kept walking. And I did not stop until I was in my car, with the doors locked, and the two papers in my bag, and the whole truth in my hands.
You may also like





