
I wanted them both and that was the sin
Chapter 2
Celine's POV
"I get what you are saying, but it hasn't been the same since that incident, Becky," I said as we both strolled down the mall, the noise of shoppers and music filling the air around us.
Becky was flipping through a rack of blouses, pulling sleeves out and holding them against herself with that unbothered energy she always carried, but my mind was somewhere else entirely. It was always somewhere else these days.
Every night I lay in that bed, staring at the ceiling, and it plays like a film I can't turn off his hands, his kisses, the sounds he made, the way he looked at me like I was something worth having. Every single detail printed so deep into my mind that sleep feels less like rest and more like a private cinema I check into alone.
"I imagine him every night, Becky," I admitted, lowering my voice even though no one around us cared. "The kisses, the touch, every single detail is just… there. And I would give everything to have it again."
She didn't even look up from the blouse she was examining. "Unluckily for you, he is currently avoiding you though, right?" she said, flipping the price tag over casually like she hadn't just pressed directly on the bruise.
I sighed, the kind that starts in your chest and drags itself all the way out. "Yes, he is," I replied, and even I could hear how hollow my voice sounded. "He practically avoids staying in the same room with me. He leaves the house early, comes back late most times he doesn't even sleep inside. And somehow I feel guilty about it."
Becky finally looked at me then, a knowing look that I both needed and dreaded. "Yes, I agree with you on that, Celine. You should feel guilty." She set the blouse back and picked up a stick of butter from a nearby stand, checking the price with the same casual ease. "I mean you had sex with a man that is supposed to father you."
"And he does," I said quietly, more to myself than to her. "I swear he does. Better than my father ever did no offense, Dad but it's the truth. He gives me everything without me even asking. He made sure I was okay, made sure I felt whole, and I never felt the absence of my father the way I used to. I'm grateful for that." I paused, watching the crowd pass around us as we made our way to the checkout. "But I can't help the feeling growing inside of me, Becky. I just can't."
She sighed at that the kind of sigh that meant she understood but wasn't going to say what I wanted to hear.
"Maybe you should tell him how you feel."
I turned to look at her like she had just suggested I jump off a bridge. "Me? No way."
"Why not?"
"Because it would sound so weird to him," I said, closing the car boot after we loaded our bags in.
"Then you see why you should get over the feelings, Celine." She adjusted her seatbelt with a firm click. "It can't work, alright?"
"You are not helping me here, Becky."
She shook her head. "Stop living in your imagination and face reality. Mr. Evans is way above you, my love. You need to stop messing with your young mind and find someone your age."
I said nothing. I just fixed my eyes on the road and let her words sit in the air between us, heavy and uncomfortable. She wasn't wrong, and that was the worst part.
The drive home was easy after that she asked about my job hunting, I told her it was going fine, no responses yet but I was hopeful. She mentioned I could ask Evans for help and I shut that down immediately. He had already done enough. The rest of the drive was us talking about boys, laughing, pretending the heavier conversation hadn't happened.
At her place, I helped carry her bags up to her apartment. That was when my phone buzzed.
Evans.
My heart did this ridiculous, embarrassing leap the moment I saw his name on the screen.
"Hi," I whispered, answering before the second ring.
"Hey Celine, how are you?" His voice was calm, measured careful in the way it had been since that night.
"I'm good," I said, keeping mine steady.
"Okay, that's nice. So uhm I'll be home late, but I don't know if you could make dinner for me. Don't worry, I'll have it microwaved when I get back."
"Okay, sure. I will."
"Alright then, thank you. Don't wait up for me, okay?"
"Alright. Bye."
The call ended and I just… slumped right there on Becky's couch, the phone resting on my chest.
"Let me guess," Becky said, reading my face before I could arrange it. "Knight in shining armor?" She made dramatic hand gestures and I laughed in spite of myself.
"Yeah. He was actually talking to me." I sat up. "He asked me to make dinner and not wait up late."
"So what's wrong with that?"
"Becky, he doesn't come home late. No matter how crazy the workload gets, he doesn't come home late. Something is wrong and I think I need to make things right between us."
She took my hand gently. "Listen, I don't know what to tell you but do what's best for you, okay?"
I smiled and pulled her into a hug. "Thank you, Becky."
By evening I was home, showered, and standing over the stove making dinner, the whole apartment quiet around me. I sat in the living room and waited patient in a way I rarely am until I heard the back door open.
He came through the back door. Like I was something to be avoided inside his own home.I was on my feet before I could think about it.
"Why are you avoiding me?" I said, walking straight into his room without knocking.
He startled, spinning around. "Oh my God, Celine, you scared me—"
"That didn't answer my question."
He sighed. "I'm not—"
"Don't lie to me, Evans." I cut him off, arms folded tight across my chest. "It's about what happened, isn't it? You feel guilty."
He looked away. "We shouldn't be having this conversation. You need to go to bed."
Something cracked open in my chest. "Well I can't, because I want it every night." My voice rose before I could stop it, and I stopped trying. "Do you know how bad I have always wanted you? I have touched myself to sleep moaning your name and that one night I had with you made me realize you felt the same way. But you're pushing it aside and I want to understand why." My voice broke at the edges. "Am I not enough? I want to be the girl you want, Evans. I want to be the girl that gives you pleasure just like other girls do, I don’t want you to see me as a child anymore. What is wrong with asking for that?"
"Celine," he said quietly, "it's not as easy as you think."
"Then make me understand. Please." I crossed the room and placed my hand flat against his bare chest, feeling the heat of his skin beneath my palm. "I want to, Evans."
I pressed my lips to his chest, soft and deliberate, and his breath hitched.
"Celine, stop." He pulled my hand away but didn't step back. "We are two different age brackets. I don't want to betray your father I made a promise to him."
"He is dead," I whispered. "And so is the promise." I reached up and turned his face to mine. "Look at me."
"Celine, please don't make this hard for me."
"I can't help it. And it's either you make love to me or I move out and never come back."
He stared at me. "You're joking."
"Try me."
I turned and walked back to my room, pulling my suitcase from under the bed. My hands were shaking as I unzipped it but I didn't stop. I heard his footsteps behind me, felt his presence in the doorway, then felt his hand close around my wrist.
He pulled me back gently until my back was against his chest.
"Okay," he said, his voice low and rough. "Fine. Is that what you want?"
And before I could answer, his mouth found mine not soft, not questioning with the kind of certainty that made my knees forget their job.
You may also like





