
I wanted them both and that was the sin
I wanted them both and that was the sin Chapter 1
Celine's POV
"Oh my God, Evan—"
His name left my lips like a confession before I could stop it, breathless and shameful all at once. I lay there staring at the ceiling of my room after, chest heaving, the silence pressing down on me like it was trying to make me face what I had just done. And the guilt came, like it always does.
What the hell is wrong with you, Celine.
I asked myself that a million times and never came up with an answer good enough. I rolled off the bed and went straight to the bathroom, turning the water on cold, stepping under it like it could wash the whole feeling out of me. Like it could drown the heat and the want and the embarrassing truth of it.
It didn't work.
I stepped out angrier than I went in, wrapping my towel around me and standing in front of the mirror with water dripping off my nose and my reflection looking back at me like it had questions too.
My parents are probably disgusted with me right now.
The thought sat heavy in my chest. How do you explain to anyone that you are twenty-two years old and completely, hopelessly gone over a forty-year-old man who was your father's best friend? How do you even begin to say that out loud without watching someone's face fall apart? I couldn't. So instead I said it to the mirror, which at least had the decency not to respond.
"This needs to stop, Celine." I pointed at my own reflection. "You need to stop." But I was lying and I knew it.
Because this was his house. Every corner of it breathed him — his cologne sitting in the air of the hallway, his presence in every room even when he wasn't in it. As long as I lived under this roof, ignoring him wasn't an option; it was just a performance I put on for myself and kept failing at.
The worst part? The nights he brought someone home.
I hate those nights. I would lie in my bed with my jaw tight and something ugly twisting in my chest, and sometimes I would slip out into the hallway just to hear, and then spend the rest of the night wishing it was me. Hating myself for wishing it but wishing it anyway.
I wish my parents were still alive. I wish that accident had never happened and I had never ended up here, in his house, in his world, falling into feelings I had absolutely no business falling into. Maybe then I would be normal.
Maybe then I could want someone appropriate and uncomplicated and my own age.
Do I even love him or do I just— "I need a drink," I said out loud, cutting my own thought off before it could finish itself.
I stood up from the edge of the bed and that was exactly when my phone lit up on the nightstand. I glanced at the screen.
Evan.
I stared at it for a second. Speak of the devil, I thought, pressing my lips together. I inhaled once, slow, and picked up.
"Hi, Celine." His voice came through deep and easy, the kind of voice that had no right to do what it did to me through a phone speaker. "How are you?"
"I'm good," I said, keeping mine even.
"I just wanted to check in on you — are you still heading to that sleepover you mentioned? At your friend's place?"
"Yeah, I am," I said. "Any problem?"
"Not really. Just wanted to know." A pause. "I'll see you tomorrow then."
"Yeah. Tomorrow it is."
He chuckled softly. "Okay. Take care, alright?"
The line went dead and I sat there holding the phone against my chest like an idiot, like he was still somehow inside it and I needed him close. I sighed at myself and dialed Bella.
She picked up sounding like she was already in the middle of something sharp — background noise, tension in her voice before she even said hello. I asked if she was okay. She said yes in that clipped way that meant absolutely not but don't push it. Bella and that boyfriend of hers — I was tired of worrying about it.
"Are we still doing the sleepover at Anita's?" I asked.
She sighed. "I thought I told you. We cancelled."
"Cancelled? Why?"
"Anita's dad didn't end up leaving the country. Plus she's still learning the ropes of his company, she doesn't have time."
I made a sound somewhere between understanding and disappointment.
"Who the hell are you talking to? End that call and get down here—" Bella's voice dropped. "Celine, I'll talk to you later." And she was gone.
I stared at my screen for a moment. Please just leave him, I thought, though I already knew she wouldn't.
I thought about calling Evan to let him know the night out was cancelled — he'd asked, after all — but something stopped me. There was no real reason to call. I didn't need an excuse to hear his voice and I refused to manufacture one. So I put the phone down, opened my laptop, and went through my emails instead, chasing the small hope that one of the companies I'd applied to had finally responded. Nothing.
I closed the laptop harder than necessary. I needed a job — not just for money but for my own sanity. Something that got me out of this house and out of my head. Evan had offered me a position at his company and I had turned it down flat, which was the one smart decision I had made in recent memory. Because I knew myself. I knew what would happen if I was in his space every day with a reason to be near him and no boundaries holding me at arm's length.
I turned onto my side, closed my eyes, and let the quiet pull me under.
I woke up to darkness.
I grabbed my phone. It was past seven. Evan would be home soon, if he wasn't already. I stretched, rolled out of bed, and went to the kitchen to put something together for him. Once it was done and covered in the fridge, I settled in to wait.
He didn't come.
I tried calling, but it wouldn't connect. I tried again — still the same thing. Eventually I gave up waiting and went to shower, singing along to Nicki Minaj loud enough that I didn't hear anything else — not the front door, not the footsteps.
When I came out, towel wrapped around me and still humming, I nearly stopped breathing. Evan was lying across my bed.
I stepped closer slowly, heart doing something complicated in my chest, and the smell reached me before anything else did. Alcohol, warm and heavy in the air around him.
Ah. That explained the late hour.
"Hey," I said softly, tapping his shoulder. He stirred but didn't wake — just shifted, mumbling something I couldn't make out. I shook him gently. "Evan, come on. Let me get you to your room."
I moved to help him up and that was when he lurched forward, off-balance and heavy, his hand catching my arm to steady himself, and the towel slipped.
Everything stopped.
His eyes opened properly, finding me, and the look on his face was something I had never seen there before. Not in all the time I had known him.
"Wow," he murmured, his voice low and rough. "You're beautiful."
The word landed somewhere it had no business landing and I felt it everywhere.
I don't remember making a decision after that. I don't remember thinking at all. All I remember is warmth, and the press of his lips on mine, and the way the whole night shifted into something neither of us would be able to take back.
I wanted them both and that was the sin of Contents
New Release Novels











