
When My Husband’s Mistress Tried to Kill Our Daughter
Chapter 5
The penthouse is too quiet.
It was always quiet. I used to think I liked that. Now I walk through seven thousand square feet of Italian marble and custom millwork and I understand that what I mistook for peace was just Diana not taking up space.
She never took up space. That was the thing. She moved through a room like someone who had learned, early, not to require too much of it.
I find the sketchbook on a Thursday night.
I'm going through a storage closet, looking for the Brennan Holdings file, and it's there on the second shelf in a flat gray box. Her handwriting on the side. D.A. — sketches, '19-'21. I stand there for a second. Then I pull it out.
I take it to the kitchen. I pour two fingers of bourbon. I open it.
The drawings are precise and patient and full of a voice I never let her use. A community library with a sloped green roof. A row of townhouses with deep, shaded porches. Residential units stacked around a shared courtyard with benches and a fountain and a specific, careful notation about natural light patterns in the afternoon. Pages and pages of it. Buildings she never got to build because she was attending Nelson Foundation galas and arranging my mother's dinner parties and being the perfectly composed woman on my arm.
I pour a third glass.
The bourbon doesn't help. Nothing helps. The sketchbook sits on the counter and looks at me and I look back at it and the penthouse is so quiet I can hear the ice in my glass.
I don't know where she is.
That is the thing I keep landing on. I don't know if she's in New York. I don't know if she stayed in architecture. I don't know what she looks like right now, or if she is okay, or if any part of what I did to her left a mark she is still carrying.
My mother calls on Friday morning.
'You look like a liability,' she says. No preamble. 'I've had three board members ask me about your focus this quarter. You need to be seen. There's a Whitmore girl — twenty-nine, Vassar, her father runs Atlantic Capital —'
'Mother.'
'Theodore. You cannot afford to look like you're grieving that woman.'
I hang up.
I sit at my desk and I look at the sketchbook I've carried to the office and I think: I am not grieving that woman. I am understanding, for the first time, that I never knew her. Not really. Not the way I should have.
I flew to Seattle for the Harrington summit in November.
The meetings ran long. I took a different route back to the hotel. I don't know why. Habit. Restlessness. The particular gray light of a Seattle afternoon that doesn't feel like New York.
The preschool is on a tree-lined block. Afternoon pickup. Parents and nannies and strollers on the sidewalk. I'm not paying attention. I'm looking at my phone.
Then I'm not looking at my phone.
She is standing at the fence. Maybe three years old. Dark hair. Her head is tipped sideways, watching a man walk by with a labrador, and she has her hand wrapped around one of the fence rails and she is completely still the way serious children get when something has their full attention.
I know those eyes.
I have looked at those eyes in the mirror every morning for thirty-seven years.
My briefcase hits the sidewalk. I don't feel it.
She says something to the teacher beside her. Points at the dog. Laughs — a big, unselfconscious laugh completely out of proportion to her size.
Then a woman near the gate turns, and the teacher leans down to the little girl and says something, and the little girl takes the woman's hand, and they walk toward the side entrance, and they are gone.
I stand on the pavement for a full minute. I don't move. Someone shoulders past me and keeps going.
I pick up my briefcase. I walk to the hotel. I ride the elevator to the fourteenth floor. I sit on the edge of the bed in my coat and I stare at the wall for a while.
Then I call Marcus Chen, the best private investigator in New York.
'I need everything,' I tell him. 'Fast.'
The results come in forty-eight hours.
Scout Nelson. Age three. Mother: Diana Adams Nelson, Design Director. Father: Theodore Nelson.
I read it three times. I look at the photograph — her in the preschool yard, Barnaby's name on a dog tag in another photo, Diana's professional headshot on the firm's website, calm and composed and looking directly at the camera like she is daring the world to try her.
I sweep everything off the desk.
The lamp. The report. The laptop. All of it.
I kneel on the floor of the hotel suite in the dark and press my fists to my forehead and I understand, finally, completely, without any part of me left to argue otherwise.
She was five months pregnant when I handed her the papers.
She signed them anyway. She took my daughter and she left and she built a life out of nothing in a city where no one knew her name, and she did it alone, and she did it well, and she never once called me.
Not once.
I kneel there for a long time. The city hums outside the window. Seattle keeps going without me.
As it always has.
You may also like





