Truth or Dare: My Wife's Secrets Exposed

"About last night... You know I had way too much to drink," Olivia said, wearing a fragile, pleading smile. "I said and did some incredibly stupid things, but none of it came from the heart. Please don't be mad at me."

I stayed silent, and her smile slowly petrified on her face.

Right on cue, Melissa stepped in, placing a fresh bowl of oatmeal in front of Olivia. "Ms. Bennett, your mother is still expecting both of you back at the house today."

Olivia let out a soft sigh.

"I admit I took things a step too far this time. I'll make sure Damien stays in his lane from now on, and I won't let him get carried away again, okay?"

She placed a lobster roll on my plate.

"I'm sorry," she said. "Honey, at least give me some credit for trying."

I set down my fork and cut straight to the chase. "Are we going to the Bennett residence or not?"

The drama from last night had made it all the way to a police station. I didn't need a crystal ball to know that Margaret had personally pulled strings to get Olivia out of there as fast as possible.

Whether the police report was a false alarm or not didn't matter.

Margaret would never allow the slightest speck of dirt to stick to Bennett Group's reputation.

As for our marriage, I knew exactly how her family viewed it. To them, if we could be happy, great. But if we were miserable, we just needed to sweep it under the rug and keep it on the down low.

After all, that was how most families in our circle operated.

…

When we arrived at the Bennett residence, Margaret welcomed me with a smile, as if she knew nothing about what had happened the night before.

"Ethan, you're finally here. We've been waiting for you."

As she spoke, she gave Olivia a sharp, warning nudge. "You brat. I told you to just stay home and celebrate with Ethan, but you just had to insist that you guys don't run in the same circles. Look at the drama you're causing! If you make Ethan unhappy again, see if I don't give you a piece of my mind!"

She deftly blocked any opportunity I might have had to bring up Olivia's behavior.

Wesley Bennett, my father-in-law, guided me over to the couch, opening a polished wooden display box. "Margaret and I spotted this at an auction a few days ago, and we both instantly thought of you."

Inside sat a pair of black opal cufflinks. One look at them told me they were worth a fortune.

I hesitated, remaining silent, when a sudden commotion echoed from the front door.

Damien walked right into the living room, cradling a small Maltese puppy in his arms and wearing a bright smile.

"Olivia, you're back home. I figured as much when I saw your car parked in the driveway. That's cold. You came home and didn't even tell your best friend. Look how stingy you've gotten. It's not like I held a grudge against you after getting pushed around last night."

He pretended to be upset as he set the puppy down. The moment his hands were free, he casually slapped her rear end.

The second the puppy's paws hit the floor, it started darting around the room. Suddenly, as if spooked by something, it bolted straight toward the coffee table where the gift box was resting.

Crash!

A porcelain teacup fell to the floor, striking the Maltese right on the head.

The puppy let out a sharp whimper.

Damien's expression instantly shifted. He rushed over, scooped up the puppy, and glared at me in fury.

"Ethan, can't you tolerate a helpless puppy? This is Olivia's home, not yours! Even if you hate me, you didn't have to—"

Before he could finish his performance, Wesley's face hardened.

"I'm the one who threw that cup," Wesley barked.

Damien froze, the fury draining from his eyes in an instant. "M-Mr. Bennett?"

Wesley's voice rose. "Who let the dog in? Have I not made it clear to every single person in this house that I'm allergic to dog fur?"

The entire first floor went dead silent as the maids exchanged nervous glances, none of them daring to speak.

I picked up a fresh teacup from the tray. "It's just a stray that wandered in without an invite, Dad. There's no reason to let it ruin your day."

Damien's face flushed with anger. "Who are you calling a stray?"

I didn't answer. Instead, I lifted the teapot, filling the cup with fresh tea.

Only then did Olivia seem to come back to herself, and she hurried over. "That's enough. Besides, Livie didn't break the cuff links, and Damien didn't do it on purpose either."

The puppy's name sounded awfully like a nickname for Olivia.

Damien instantly realized something was off. He reached out, tugging at her sleeve.

"Mr. Bennett, it's not what you think. It's just a puppy Olivia gave me right after you guys finalized the wedding date," he stammered. "She said she was worried I'd get incredibly lonely without her around. That's why she bought Livie to keep me company."

The rich aroma of the tea began to fill the room.

I shut my eyes.

Maybe I shouldn't have held out any hope for Olivia.

As I slowly closed my fist around the black opal cufflinks, I smiled. "Dad, whatever stunts Olivia has pulled, consider it even."

Olivia's gaze landed on my hand.

Her expression stiffened, and she looked at me in disbelief.