The Heart Knew Who It Truly Beat For

Micah's POV

“Well, well… long time no see, little sister,” Mallory slowly greeted and sat down beside me, her eyes sweeping over my outfit from head to toe.

“This look must’ve cost at least, what, a few grands?” She smirked, then pointed at the bracelet on my wrist. “And that one? At least tens of thousands, right? Gavin’s really generous with you, huh.”

She then let out a long, dramatic sigh. “You’re living the dream now, while I’ve been suffering overseas for the past two years.”

I smiled faintly. “Didn’t you say before that as long as you could be with your boyfriend, you’d live on scraps and never complain?”

“Boyfriend? What boyfriend? You don’t have a brother-in-law!” she snapped.

She leaned closer, her tone sharp and deliberate. “Let’s not waste time. I came back to reclaim what’s mine. Starting today, you’ll go back to being you, Micah, and I’ll be Mallory again. After dinner, take off that designer dress and all the jewelry, and I’ll return to the Roarkes in your place. We’ll switch back.”

I almost laughed at how shameless she sounded. “Wow, you really are something else. You think I’ll just hand over everything I’ve built these past two years? I worked hard to earn Gavin’s trust, to secure my place in that family, and you think I’ll just give it to you?”

Mallory slammed her hand against the table. “Gavin was supposed to marry me! You stole my place and enjoyed my life all this time. Did you really think you could keep it forever?”

Standing my ground, I countered, “You didn’t want to marry him back then. You almost got the whole family killed because of your cowardice! But I took your place and saved you. If anything, you should be grateful to me. And for your information, the reason I became Mrs. Roarke, the woman he dotes on, is because I earned it. You think just showing up means you can replace me?”

Fed up, Mallory shot up from her seat and shouted, “You’ve gone too far! I already let you live under my name for two years. That was mercy! If you don’t switch back now, I’ll go straight to Gavin and tell him everything!”

“I’ll tell him that you were jealous of me, that you pushed me into the river, that you caused my amnesia. Once he knows, you’ll lose everything. He’ll punish you himself, and you’ll wish you were dead!” she hissed.

Slowly, I rose from my chair, my voice calm but cold. “Go ahead. Tell him. But when you do, I’ll play the recording of that day, the one where all of you begged me to take your place and marry Gavin. Let’s see how he reacts when he hears that. If I go down, we all go down. The whole family, together.”

Before Mallory could reply, my mother stormed toward me and slapped me across the face.

“You’ll switch with your sister today, or I swear I’ll die right here in front of you!” she screamed.

I clutched my cheek, tears stinging my eyes despite my efforts to hold them back.

“Mom,” I whispered, my voice trembling, “until I saw Mallory again, I honestly believed that somewhere in your hearts, you and Dad still cared about me. But now I see clearly. You’ve only ever had one daughter, and it’s not me.”

I straightened my shoulders and added, “I’m not switching back. Not now, not ever. So, stop dreaming.”

Then I turned to leave. I wanted to get out of that house, out of their lies, before I lost control.

But just as I stepped toward the door, something slammed into the back of my head.

Pain exploded through my skull, and the world tilted sideways. I hit the floor hard, my vision blurring, blood trickling down the back of my neck.

Through the haze, I saw Mallory clutching a ceramic bear, the one I’d given her years ago for her birthday.

With a trembling voice, Mom panicked, “Mallory! That was too hard! You didn’t kill her, did you?”

Mallory looked down at me, saw my eyes still open, and exhaled in relief. “She’s still breathing.”

Then she crouched beside me, patted my cheek, and said in a low, cold voice, “See, Micah? This is what happens when you don’t know your place. If you’d just agreed to switch with me, none of this would’ve been necessary.”

My head throbbed violently. Darkness crept at the edges of my vision.

But even as everything started to fade, I clenched my teeth and fought to stay awake.