Rejected by Fate, I Chose the Beta’s Heart

Colter Cox, the Alpha of the Cox Pack, had imprisoned me in his territory without my consent. The front door was locked, and no matter how hard I tried, it wouldn’t budge. He tossed me onto the couch in the living room, while he and Zora Morales, my sister, each took over a bedroom. It was beyond me why he would demean me like this if he didn’t care for me at all. My wolf whimpered in the back of my mind, but I silenced her, refusing to let her see me this broken.

I spent a restless night curled up on the couch, the scent of pine and dominance—Colter’s scent—filling the air, making it hard to breathe. In the morning, I woke abruptly as Zora splashed cold coffee on me. I sat up and quietly tried to dry myself with tissues, my hands trembling.

"Arianna, I heard you're allergic to coffee?" she mocked, sipping from her mug with a smirk, her voice dripping with false sweetness.

When I first became Colter’s mate, he had quickly learned about my allergy and made sure the kitchen avoided it in all our meals. But with Zora’s arrival, he had his assistant deliver fresh coffee overnight just for her, because she had a morning coffee ritual. All the attentiveness he once showed me was now showered on someone else. My wolf growled faintly, a low sound of frustration, but I pushed her down.

Zora settled herself in a clear spot on the couch, her smile deceptively sweet, her eyes glinting with malice. "Arianna, guess who’s more important to Colter, you or me?"

I frowned at her, my chest tightening. “Zora, I'm not trying to compete with you. Please, just stop...” Before I could finish, she shoved her mug into my hand and then used my hand to pour the coffee on her own head. She slumped to the floor dramatically, producing a loud thud.

Just then, Colter stormed into the room, his presence as overwhelming as ever, his Alpha aura pressing down on me. His eyes were full of worry as he rushed to Zora’s aid, his voice soft but commanding. "It's okay, Zora, my sister didn't mean it," she said weakly, her voice trembling with fake innocence.

I hoped Colter would see through her act, but instead, he turned to me, his dark eyes blazing with anger. Without a word, he slapped me across the face, the sharp sound echoing in the room.

“Arianna, how could you be so spiteful? Apologize to Zora!” he ordered, his Alpha tone leaving no room for argument. I bit my lip, my cheek stinging, and retorted, “Colter, are you blind? Can't you see that she—”

He slapped me again, harder this time, the force of it making my head snap to the side. “Arianna, you always find a way to astonish me! No wonder your father, Alpha Francisco, won’t let you come back home; you deserve it!”

Tears streamed down my face as I turned away to wipe them, my wolf howling in pain inside me. Until now, I had only regretted getting involved with Colter. In this moment, I wished I had never met him.

“Let it go, Colter. I'm fine, she probably just didn't sleep well last night,” Zora said, pretending to be weak, her voice soft and understanding. Colter’s focus remained squarely on her, and he shot me a furious look before carrying her out, slamming the door shut behind him.

I sank back onto the couch, my body trembling, my wolf’s grief mingling with my own. The mate bond between Colter and me, once so strong, now felt like a chain, heavy and suffocating. I whispered to myself, “I can’t do this anymore,” my wolf echoing the sentiment with a low, mournful whine. But deep down, I knew this was only the beginning of the storm.