Reborn To Reign: Choosing The Monster Over The Prince

Abby Talley POV

The Herald cleared his throat, the sound sharp in the cavernous silence, as he opened the heavy ceremonial ledger.

"Abigail Talley," he intoned, his voice echoing off the vaulted ceiling. "Daughter of Soldier Mark Talley. You stand before the Don to fulfill the blood debt of your father. Do you pledge yourself to Capo Connor Walls?"

The entire room seemed to hold its breath, waiting for the rehearsed submission. The expected "I do."

Connor straightened his silk tie, that familiar, smug grin reclaiming his face. He clearly believed the earlier friction with Brannon was nothing more than a hiccup—a momentary lapse that the system was designed to correct.

I shifted my gaze to the Don. The old man watched me from his high seat, his eyes sharp with curiosity. He was a predator who respected only one thing: strength. He respected the code above all else.

"No," I said.

The word was soft, barely a whisper, but in the suffocating silence, it detonated like a bomb.

Connor's smile didn't just fade; it evaporated. "What did you say?"

I ignored him, turning my eyes to Brannon. He stood like a statue carved from obsidian, his hands loose at his sides, radiating a terrifying readiness.

"The debt requires a union with the Walls bloodline," I stated, my voice gaining a steel edge. "It does not specify the heir."

I took a steadying breath. This was it. The precipice.

"I choose Brannon Walls."

The sound that rippled through the crowd wasn't shock; it was pure horror. The Butcher? The man who existed in the shadows? No woman chose Brannon. He was the nightmare, never the dream.

"You can't be serious!" Connor shrieked, his composure shattering. He broke rank from his men, charging toward me with wild eyes. "She's insane! She belongs to me!"

He reached for me, his expression a mask of furious possession.

I didn't flinch. I didn't have to.

Brannon intercepted him.

It wasn't a frantic struggle. It was a collision of chaos and order. One second Connor was lunging; the next, he was stopped dead in his tracks. Brannon had caught Connor's wrist in mid-air, halting his momentum with terrifying ease.

"Let go of her," Connor spat, his face turning a mottled purple with rage. "You'll pay for this, you freak!"

Brannon didn't yell. He didn't posture. He simply twisted.

Snap.

A sickening sound echoed in the sudden silence.

Connor cried out, a sharp, agonized sound, his knees buckling. He collapsed to the floor, clutching his now unnaturally bent wrist to his chest.

But Brannon wasn't finished. He held Connor down by the broken limb, forcing his brother to bow before me in a gruesome parody of respect.

"Touch her again," Brannon said, his voice flat, utterly devoid of emotion, "and you will face a consequence you cannot imagine."

He lifted his head, his dark, abyssal eyes challenging every Capo, every soldier, every made man in the room.

"She is under my protection," Brannon declared.

It wasn't a request for permission. It was a statement of fact. A claiming.

The Don stood up slowly. He looked down at Connor, weeping on the floor, disgraced and broken by his own lack of discipline. Then he looked at Brannon—the lethal weapon who had just displayed more control and raw power in ten seconds than his brother had in a lifetime.

The Don nodded once.

"So be it," the Don ruled. "Write it in the ledger."

Brannon released Connor, who scrambled away like a wounded animal, cradling his arm, muttering curses under his breath.

Brannon turned to me. He reached out, his large, calloused hand hovering near my face. He didn't touch the mark Connor had left. Instead, he touched my other cheek, his thumb grazing my skin with a gentleness that terrified me far more than his violence ever could.

"There is no going back, Abby," he warned, his voice a low rumble vibrating in his chest. "You just chose a life in the shadows with me."

I leaned into his touch, grounding myself in the heat of him, the solid, unbreakable reality of him.

"I'm not afraid of beasts, Brannon," I whispered. "I'm afraid of false princes."

He stared at me for a long moment, searching my eyes for fear, but finding only resolve. Then, for the first time, the Butcher smiled. It was a dark, terrifying thing.

"Good," he said. "Because I'm never letting you go."