
My Sister Seduced Every Man I Loved
Chapter 2
The restaurant was tucked between a bookstore and a wine shop on a West Village street I'd walked past a hundred times without noticing. No sign out front. Just a red door with a brass handle and a small window glowing warm against the evening dark.
Cassian held the door for me. Inside, the space was smaller than my apartment. Six tables. Exposed brick. The smell of garlic and fresh bread and something sweet baking. An older man with white hair and an apron looked up from behind a counter and smiled like he'd been expecting us.
"Cassian," he said. "Your table is ready."
We sat in the back corner. The table had a candle in a wine bottle. Wax had dripped down the sides in layers. Years of it. The menu was handwritten in Italian. No prices.
Cassian ordered for both of us. The owner nodded and disappeared into the kitchen.
"You come here a lot," I said.
"Once a week. Sometimes twice." He leaned back in his chair. The candlelight made shadows under his cheekbones. "I like places where people know me. Where I don't have to explain myself."
I looked down at my hands. The black dress had felt powerful in my apartment. Now it felt like armor I didn't know how to wear.
"I remember you," Cassian said.
I looked up. "From NYU."
"From orientation. You were in the theater program group. You laughed at something the advisor said. A real laugh. Not polite. Everyone else was trying so hard to look serious and artistic. You just laughed."
I didn't remember that. Didn't remember him being there.
"I saw your production junior year," he continued. "The contemporary urban piece. The one where you played the woman trapped in her apartment building. You were extraordinary."
My throat tightened. That production. The one Salem had used. The footage she'd twisted into something ugly.
"I saw you in Washington Square Park once," he said. "You were sketching buildings. There was some party happening. Everyone was drunk on the lawn. You were sitting alone with a notebook, drawing the arch from different angles."
The owner brought wine. Poured two glasses. Left the bottle.
"Why are you telling me this?" I asked.
"Because I've watched you be brave for a very long time." His voice was quiet. Steady. "And I'd like to be someone you don't have to be brave around."
I picked up my wine glass. Set it down without drinking. "You don't know me."
"I know you worked three jobs to pay for your own textbooks even though your parents could afford it. I know you won the Steinhardt Prize for your thesis on adaptive reuse in urban spaces. I know your sister submitted the same thesis under her own name and your parents made the university bury it."
I stared at him. "How do you know that?"
"I pay attention."
The pasta came. Handmade pappardelle with wild boar ragu. The owner set the plates down gently and left without a word.
I didn't pick up my fork. "Why?"
"Why what?"
"Why pay attention to me? Why remember all of this? Why now?"
Cassian looked at me for a long moment. "Because I've been waiting for you to be ready."
"Ready for what?"
"To stop protecting people who hurt you. To stop making yourself smaller so your sister can feel bigger. To stop believing you deserve what they've done to you."
I felt something crack inside my chest. Small. Sharp. Like the first line in glass before it shatters.
"I saw your livestream," he said. "That took courage. Real courage. Not the kind where you smile and pretend everything is fine. The kind where you tell the truth even when it costs you something."
"It's going to cost me everything," I said. My voice came out rough. "My family. My mother's already called me seventeen times. My father sent an email with the subject line 'Family Loyalty.' Salem is probably planning something right now. Something worse."
"Good," Cassian said.
I blinked. "Good?"
"Let them show you who they are. Let them prove you were right to walk away. And when they do—" He leaned forward. "I'll be standing next to you."
"You don't owe me anything."
"I'm not offering because I owe you. I'm offering because I want to. Because I've wanted to for seven years. Because watching you suffer while pretending I didn't know you was the hardest thing I've ever done."
I picked up my fork. Put it down. "I don't understand."
"You will," he said. "Eat. Then I'll take you home. And tomorrow, when Salem does whatever she's planning, you won't face it alone."
I ate. The pasta was perfect. Rich and complex and exactly right. Like someone had known exactly what I needed.
When we left, Cassian put his hand on the small of my back. Light. Steady. Like he'd done it a thousand times before.
The owner called out from behind the counter. "See you next week, Cassian. Bring her again."
Cassian smiled. "I will."
Outside, the street was quiet. Cold. I pulled my coat tighter.
"Thank you," I said. "For dinner."
"Thank you," he said, "for giving me the chance to finally stop watching from a distance."
He drove me home. Walked me to my door. Waited until I was inside before he left.
I stood in my apartment. Took off the black dress. Hung it carefully in my closet.
Something I feel powerful in.
My phone buzzed. A text from Cassian. *Sleep well. Tomorrow's going to be interesting.*
I almost smiled. Almost.
Then I saw the notification. An event invitation. A gallery opening. Tomorrow night. And in the comments, Salem had already RSVP'd yes.
I looked at the black dress hanging in my closet.
Interesting. That was one word for it.
You may also like





