
My Fiancé Married His “Dying” Best Friend
Chapter 3
Jordan's phone kept buzzing. He pulled it out, glanced at the screen, and hit silence. He didn't even look at who it was. That was new.
He pointed the roses at Theodore like a weapon. "I'm going to ask one more time. Who the hell are you?"
I didn't wait for the answer. I turned and walked into my bedroom.
I knew exactly what I was looking for. A small shoebox on the closet shelf. Inside was his spare key, his gray college hoodie, and a pair of cufflinks he'd left on my nightstand months ago. I had packed it on Tuesday at two in the morning, between batches of lemon tarts.
Through the thin wall, I heard Theodore's voice. Warm. Unhurried.
"Theodore Mason," he said. "It's nice to finally meet you."
Then nothing.
No explanation. No *we're just friends*. No *it's not what it looks like*. Just silence, long and heavy, like a held breath.
I heard Jordan shift his weight. I heard the roses crackle again. I heard him exhale through his nose, the way he did when a waiter got his order wrong.
"Finally?" Jordan said. "What's that supposed to mean?"
Theodore didn't answer.
I came back out with the box. Jordan's eyes snapped to me. They were a little too bright.
I looked at the roses. Two dozen. Black paper. A tiny gold card tucked inside. I knew without reading it what it said. Something about forever. Something his assistant wrote.
I used to love red roses. I told him once that I liked tulips better. Yellow ones. He nodded and kept buying roses.
I held out the box. "These are yours. Now leave."
He didn't take it. "Stell. Come on."
"Leave, Jordan."
His face softened. He tilted his head, the way he did when he wanted to look hurt. "After five years, you can't even have a conversation with me? That's really who you are now?"
There it was. The script. Make her the cruel one. Make her feel small for wanting basic respect.
For five years, that line would have worked. I would have apologized. I would have said, *You're right, let's talk.*
I didn't say anything.
I set the box on the floor at his feet. Then I reached past him and pulled the door open wider. All the way, until it touched the wall.
And I waited.
The hallway light buzzed. Somewhere downstairs, Mrs. Alvarez's TV played a game show. Davina sipped her coffee very loudly.
Jordan looked at me. Then at Theodore, who hadn't moved an inch. Then back at me.
His jaw worked. He bent down, grabbed the box, and tucked it under his arm. The roses stayed clutched in his other hand.
He walked out.
He didn't even leave the flowers. I watched them go down the hallway, bobbing red against his dark coat. His phone started buzzing again before he reached the stairs.
I closed the door. My hand was shaking. I pressed it flat against the wood until it stopped.
---
Theodore left an hour later. He said goodbye to Davina. Then he looked at me for a long second.
"Goodnight, Estelle," he said. Like my name was something fragile he was afraid to drop.
That evening, Davina and I sat on the floor eating cold lo mein from the carton.
"Okay," I said. "Who is he really?"
She twirled her noodles. "Theodore."
"Davina."
"He's a good guy."
"I've met good guys. Good guys don't show up with my favorite croissants from a bakery I never told you about."
She smiled into her carton. "He's been in love with you for a very long time, babe."
I stared at her. "I met him today."
"Did you, though?" She shrugged. "Just give him a chance. That's all I'm saying."
"I'm not doing this again. I'm not handing my life to some man and hoping he doesn't drop it."
"I know." Her voice went soft. "That's why it's him."
She wouldn't say more. I pushed. She changed the subject to her nightmare client.
But later, alone on my mattress, I kept seeing him by the window. The way he went still when I talked. The way he didn't fill the silence. The way his eyes looked like a song I almost remembered.
I touched my left earlobe in the dark. Then I made myself stop.
---
The next morning, there was a white paper bag outside my door.
I almost stepped on it. I picked it up carefully, like it might explode. The logo was from Marguerite's, the tiny bakery on Atlantic Avenue. Inside was one almond croissant. Still warm.
My order. Not chocolate. Almond. The one I only got on good days.
Taped to the bag was a folded card. Thick, cream-colored paper. Neat handwriting in dark ink.
*You don't have to love me back yet. I have the rest of my life to wait.*
*— T.*
I stood in the hallway in my socks.
Five years. Jordan never learned my coffee order. Not once. He'd hand me a vanilla latte and say, *I got your usual*, and I'd smile and drink it because it was easier than reminding him.
And this man. This stranger. He knew which croissant I picked on good days.
Something cracked open in my chest.
I sat down right there on the hallway floor. The bag crinkled in my lap. I pressed the card to my mouth, and I cried. Not the ugly sobbing from the wedding night. Something quieter. Something that felt almost like relief.
The next morning, there was another bag.
And the morning after that.
I started waking up before my alarm. Just to listen for footsteps.
I never heard any. Whoever left them was careful. Patient.
Like he had done this before. Like he'd been waiting a very long time.
You may also like





