
My Boyfriend Betrayed Me for the Heiress Who Stole My Life
Chapter 2
The nurse at the private clinic on East 68th Street swabbed my cheek at seven a.m. sharp. She didn't ask questions. People who work for women like Vivienne Whitmore never do.
When I stepped back into the waiting room, shivering in my thin dress, Vivienne stood up. She slid off her camel cashmere coat and settled it over my shoulders.
"I'm not going to tell you what to believe," she said. "Not until we know."
"Okay."
"But you haven't eaten since yesterday." She paused. "What would you like for breakfast?"
I opened my mouth. Nothing came out.
In Denise's house, I ate what was left. Cold fries. The burnt edge of the casserole. Nobody had ever asked me what I wanted.
My eyes stung. I blinked hard and stared at the floor.
"Pancakes," I managed. "If that's not stupid."
"It's not stupid." Her voice wobbled. "Pancakes it is."
---
By noon I was on a bus to Scranton. Before the results came back, I had to hear it from Denise herself.
The kitchen smelled like cheap whiskey. Denise sat at the table with her husband, Gary, a bottle between them. She didn't get up when I walked in.
"Well, look who crawled home." Her eyes swept over me, then narrowed on the coat. "Where'd you get that?"
"Borrowed it."
"From who?" She leaned forward. "It was all over the internet. Some Whitmore woman grabbed you at a party. Did they give you money?"
Not *are you hurt*. Not *what happened to your hand*.
I let my shoulders sag. "Money? Hotel security threw me out on the sidewalk. Some rich lady confused me with someone. That's all."
Denise breathed out. Her whole body softened, like a balloon losing air. Gary snorted and refilled his glass.
"Figures." She tapped her nails on the table. "Anyway, good timing. Your Uncle Ray owes five grand to some guys in Wilkes-Barre. You're covering it."
"No."
The word just dropped out of me.
Denise tilted her head. "Excuse me?"
"I said no. I've paid his debts twice. I'm done."
She moved fast. She always had. The glass left her hand before I could duck. It clipped my shoulder and shattered against the fridge behind me.
"Twenty-two years!" she screamed. "Twenty-two years I fed you, clothed you, put a roof over your ungrateful head! And now your wings are grown, you think you can say no to *me*?"
I didn't flinch. That surprised both of us.
In my coat pocket, my phone was already recording. I'd pressed the button on the porch.
"Why don't I look like you?" I asked quietly.
The kitchen went still.
"What?"
"Your eyes are brown. Gary's are brown. Mine are gray. I'm five-eight and you're five-two. I don't look like a single person in this family." I stepped closer. "And why is my birth certificate scratched out? The hospital name. Somebody wrote over it in pen."
Denise's face changed. Something flickered underneath the anger, quick as a fish under ice.
"You went through my things?"
"I made a copy when I applied for my passport. I just never asked." I pulled the folded paper from my bag. "I'm asking now."
Gary lunged across the table. His chair crashed backward. He ripped the page out of my fingers and crumpled it in his fist.
"Get out," he growled.
Denise didn't shout this time. She laughed, low and cold, and picked up the bottle.
"Even if you were born a princess, you're still nothing without money."
I looked at her for a long moment. The woman who taught me to tie my shoes. The woman who slapped my hand away from a tin box.
Then I went upstairs, packed one duffel bag, and left. I didn't say goodbye.
---
The results came at six that evening.
Vivienne read the report in the back of her car. Then she folded over it like someone had cut her strings. The sound she made wasn't crying. It was older than crying.
"99.98 percent," she choked out. "You're mine. You were always mine."
I sat beside her, frozen. I wanted to say *Mom*. The word sat in my throat like a stone.
"I'm sorry," I whispered. "I don't know how to... not yet."
"Don't apologize." She wiped her face with the heel of her hand. "You don't owe me anything."
"How did it happen?"
She stared out the window. "I gave birth at a private hospital in Philadelphia. You had trouble breathing right after. They rushed you to the NICU. Just for a few hours." Her voice cracked. "One of the nurses on that shift was named Denise Mercer."
My nails bit into my palms.
"When they brought my baby back, she was fine. I never questioned it." She laughed bitterly. "Brielle was born with a heart defect. I flew in surgeons from Zurich. I spent millions keeping her alive. And all that time, you were..."
She couldn't finish.
"I'll find out everything," she said. "Every name. Every signature. But I will never ask you to forgive anyone. Including me."
---
The Whitmore house on the Upper East Side had more staircases than Denise's whole street had doors.
Brielle stood halfway down the main one in a champagne silk robe. Her eyes were red and swollen, like she'd been crying for hours. Or practicing.
"Mom." Her voice broke perfectly. "Are you replacing me?"
Before Vivienne could answer, the front door opened. A tall man with silver hair rushed in, tie loose, briefcase still in hand.
Richard Whitmore. My father.
He looked at me for exactly two seconds. Then his eyes went to Brielle, and his face crumpled.
"Sweetheart." He held out his arms, and she ran into them. Over her head, he turned to us. "Viv, we raised her for twenty-two years. She's still our girl. Why can't they live here together? As sisters?"
I said nothing. Sisters.
Brielle pulled away from him and floated toward me. She took my injured hand in both of hers, gentle as a nurse.
"I'd love that," she said warmly. "Sienna, you can have half my closet. Half my jewelry. Anything you need. You've had such a hard life."
Like I was a poor cousin who'd come begging.
"Sienna isn't here to share your life," Vivienne said coldly. "She is here to reclaim hers."
Brielle's grip tightened for half a second. Then she smiled.
---
"Let me show you your room," she offered later, already walking.
She led me past three closed doors to the end of a narrow back hall. The room inside held a single bed and a dresser. One window. It faced a brick wall.
"This used to be the maid's room," she said lightly. "Cozy, right?"
"It's fine."
She leaned against the doorframe. "Just so you know, Mom feels guilty. It'll pass. In a month, Dad will remember who actually knows how to behave at a gala." She glanced at my faded dress. "Breeding matters here."
I set down my duffel bag.
"Can I ask you something?"
"Of course."
"Last night, when your mother said the name Denise Mercer, everyone else was confused." I watched her face. "You weren't. Why weren't you surprised?"
Her eyes darted left. Just once.
Then she laughed. "I've never heard that name in my life. Goodnight, Sienna."
---
At two a.m., my throat was dry. I crept downstairs barefoot.
The kitchen's back door was cracked open. Cold air drifted in, and with it, a voice from the garden. Low. Furious.
Brielle.
I pressed myself into the shadow beside the pantry.
"I don't care what she has," Brielle hissed into her phone. "She was in the house tonight. In my house."
A pause.
"No. Listen to me." Her voice dropped to a snarl I'd never heard from her. "Mom, I told you to destroy those hospital records years ago!"
My hand flew to my mouth.
*Mom.*
Not Vivienne. Vivienne was asleep upstairs.
Brielle was talking to Denise.
And she had known. All this time, she had known exactly who I was.
You may also like





